Paul Wellstone: Harkin's triumphant lament

By Antonio Valle del Rio
October 30, 2002

MINNEAPOLIS, MN - Last night there was a memorial service for the late Senator Paul Wellstone and the others killed in the plane crash last Friday. It was held at Williams Arena on the University of Minnesota campus. Twenty-thousand people were inside, and many more out in the night chill watching on "jumbo-trons" or whatever. I assume not many people were watching C-Span in the middle of the night, so I will recap some highlights (like it or not).
     Preface: Wellstone was my favorite senator even before I moved to Minnesota. He had the guts to admit he was a liberal, or even a progressive (not dirty words for him). He opposed the Gulf War, voted against welfare "reform" (even though many said it would cost him reelection--guess what, it didn't), opposed giving billions of dollars to the Colombian military (he actually visited Colombia to research where the dough would go), and fought against international trafficking of women and children. He was followed in excellence, in my mind, by Senator Tom Harkin (D-Iowa)--not only because Harkin's staff helped expedite the visas for my wife and step-daughter, but because Harkin has also been fairly liberal himself.
     The memorial was upbeat from the start, with soul music and inspirational speeches by friends and family of the campaign workers and advisers and the bodyguard who were killed. Then the surviving Wellstone sons spoke. They were positive and upbeat, mostly reflecting on memories of their mom, dad, and sister.
     A former Saint Paul mayor moderated the event, and he commented that everyone knew who should "wrap up" the service. A few days before, Tom Harkin had stepped up to a nest of microphones to give a press conference on Wellstone's death, and before he could say anything, he lost it, breaking down into convulsive sobbing.
     Now Harkin bowed his head in concentration as the cameras pointed to him. He rose to the podium amidst the applause, which was coming from the likes of Pres. Clinton, Senators Kennedy, Daschle, Rodham-Clinton, Lieberman, even Lott and Domenici, plus Walter Mondale, Jesse Jackson and Al Gore. (Jesse Ventura was booed when he entered the arena--he looked pretty pissed about that, as you can imagine--and had already left because the speeches were getting too "partisan." He later said that he felt "violated.")
     Harkin was composed. He spoke in a natural way about the first time he met Wellstone, how short and disheveled he seemed the first time Harkin saw him, at a meeting with farmers in Austin, Minnesota, about the Harkin-Gephardt Bill to save the family farmers. This was in the middle of the Reagan years, and I remember how in the mid 1980s a farmer in a small Iowa town who was having his farm foreclosed killed some people, including his banker and I believe his family, and then himself. Harkin said, "As the senator, they had me speak last. Right before me, they brought up this little guy..." (Laughter) "He was wearing a t-shirt, and he had long curly hair. But he spoke with passion. Later, I told my staff, Don't you ever put me on the podium after that guy again."
     The joke about Wellstone in 1990 was that he was the only one who got a raise by being elected to the Senate. They apparently had to buy him some suits.
     He related the story that Wellstone had often told him, about one of his first speeches on the senate floor. After giving it, Senator Ernest Hollings came up to him and in his southern drawl said, "'You reminded me of Hubert Humphrey.'"
     "Paul swelled with pride. Then the senior senator added, 'You talk too much.'" (Laughter.)
     Harkin continued: "He was able to bring people together: environmentalists and labor, Republicans and Democrats--he even brought Minnesotans and Iowans together!" (Laughter.)
     "He was my best friend in the Senate, and he was one of those rare people who many thought of as their best friend.
     "Sometimes, he even disagreed with his friends, on war, on welfare. But when he did, he was the mirror we looked into to search our own souls."
     Then came the fire. Harkin rallied the crowd with comments on domestic abuse and domestic violence, world peace, ending discrimination based on race, color, religion, or sexual orientation: "Are we going to fight for social justice and economic justice, for Paul? Say yes!" And the crowd roared, "YES!" "For Paul, are we going to fight to end domestic violence against women and children? Say yes!" "YES!" "For Paul, are we going to fight for better wages for those who mop our floors, clean our bathrooms, care for our elderly, those who have been left on the roadside of life? Say yes!" "YES!"